AEW faction reforms, Another setback & more - 5 Potential twists in the Toni Storm saga after her memory loss
Toni Storm's return on the latest episode of Dynamite has shaken things up in the AEW Women's division. The Illustrious seems to have dropped the Timeless persona, which has raised several questions regarding her future.
Storm seems to have no memories of her time as the 1920s Hollywood Starlet. The 29-year-old star apparently believes she is just starting out in AEW, having no recollection of her iconic reign as the AEW Women's World Champion.
In less than a week of her return, Toni Storm has become one of the most fascinating characters on the AEW roster. Several intriguing developments are set to unfold as Storm goes through her current identity crisis phase. In this article, let's look at five potential twists that could happen in The Rockstar's saga following her memory loss.
#5. Toni Storm could go on a losing streak in AEW
The last few months have been quite forgettable for Toni Storm. At All In 2024, The Timeless Superstar lost her AEW Women's World Championship against her arch-nemesis, Mariah May.
Following the crushing loss, Storm took a hiatus from AEW to compete in STARDOM and CMLL. The Illustrious suffered crucial losses against Mayu Iwatani and La Catalina, seemingly breaking her confidence.
Back-to-back defeats in other promotions could have had a massive psychological impact on Storm, mentally causing her to dissociate from the Timeless character. However, the former WWE star's win-loss record might not improve even after she switched back to the Rockstar persona.
In the coming weeks, the former NXT UK Women's Champion could go on a losing streak, which would greatly crush her confidence. The New Zealand-born star could also struggle to outsmart her opponents in the ring, something she frequently did as the vintage actress.
#4. The Outcasts could reform for a brief period
Toni Storm is in a vulnerable spot at the moment. Having lost her memory, The Timeless Superstar has no knowledge of anyone she crossed paths with in the last two years.
With The Illustrious having no allies in her corner, several faces from Toni Storm's past could emerge to confront her soon. While she is currently away from in-ring competition, Saraya would certainly be interested in recruiting the 29-year-old star yet again.
The Anti-Diva could soon approach The Rockstar with an offer to reform The Outcasts. Storm would be blown away by Saraya's generous offer and immediately join forces with the iconic star.
It could lead to a short revival of The Outcasts, with Harley Cameron being a like-to-like replacement for Ruby Soho. Saraya could take advantage of Storm's gullibility and force her to do her dirty work.
After a few weeks, the New Zealand-born star could recognize Saraya's wicked plan and leave the faction with immediate effect. It would be an intriguing mini-arc for Toni Storm so that she stays away from Mariah May for a little longer.
#3. The Rockstar could challenge Mercedes Mone for the TBS Championship
Toni Storm is one of the most well-established stars on the AEW roster. As The Timeless Superstar, Storm has scaled incredible heights in the Jacksonville-based promotion.
A contest between Toni Storm and Mercedes Mone is one of the biggest matches Tony Khan could book at the moment. However, The Illustrious' ongoing identity crisis could be a way for TK to give fans a glimpse of a rivalry between the two performers.
The former NXT UK Women's Champion believes herself to be a rookie, and she only joined AEW on this week's Dynamite. A hungry Toni Storm would be eager to add some gold to her title collection, resulting in her challenging Mercedes Mone for the TBS Championship.
Even though she is not in her Timeless era, the 29-year-old star could still be a massive threat to the CEO. Storm could test herself against the reigning TBS Champion before setting her sights on the AEW Women's World Championship.
#2. Mariah May could manipulate Storm into being her ally
Mariah May is arguably the biggest reason behind Toni Storm's sudden memory loss. The Glamour pretended to be a trustworthy protege to Storm for months, which allowed her to get close to the Timeless Superstar.
In July 2024, May launched a heinous assault on her mentor after winning the Owen Hart Foundation Tournament. The Fighting Princess then went on to dethrone Toni Storm at All In 2024, taking away her most prized possession.
Although the 29-year-old star has no memories of her feud with Mariah May, The Glamour can not rule out the threat of Storm eyeing her championship. The 26-year-old star could devise another strategy to neutralize her former mentor before she becomes a problem.
The Fighting Princess could develop a friendship with The Rockstar to keep her away from the AEW Women's World Championship. It could be an intriguing alliance where Storm and May would switch their previous roles as mentor and protege.
The partnership could last till a month before All In 2025, when the former Outcasts member could finally regain her memories.
#1. Toni Storm could snap back into her Timeless persona and recapture the AEW Women's World Championship
Toni Storm's "Timeless" persona has been one of the most successful creative ideas AEW has presented on television. Even though she has no recollection of the iconic gimmick, it is highly unlikely that the former NXT UK Women's Champion will ever be in her vintage avatar again.
The rivalry between Mariah May and her mentor could possibly conclude at All In 2025. Till then, Toni Storm could play the role of a rookie babyface and struggle to find her spot on the roster.
Right before All In 2025, Storm could earn a shot at the AEW Women's World Title, possibly by winning the Owen Hart Foundation Tournament. The Illustrious' remarkable win could cause her to be brutally attacked by The Glamour.
The incident could act as a catalyst for the return of the Timeless Superstar, as the "No memory" arc of Toni Storm could finally come to an end. At All In 2025, the 29-year-old star could once again revel in her Hollywood Starlet persona and end Mariah May's title reign.
It would be a satisfying conclusion to the May vs. Storm rivalry, which has been one of the best feuds in the history of All Elite Wrestling.