10 One Piece Characters who need to stay dead for the plot
The world of One Piece is filled with incredible characters whose legacies continue to impact the story even after their deaths. These deaths play an important role in shaping the plot, driving character growth, and keeping the stakes high. Bringing back certain characters could weaken the story’s core themes of sacrifice and passing on one’s will.
From legendary figures like Joy Boy and Gol D. Roger to heartfelt losses like Nico Olvia and Kozuki Toki, their deaths have deep meaning. This article looks at ten One Piece characters whose deaths are essential to the story and should remain permanent.
Joy Boy and 9 other One Piece characters who shouldn't return from the dead
1) Joy Boy
Joy Boy’s death is vital to the themes and story of One Piece. His sacrifice as a liberator against oppression creates a legacy of freedom for future generations, like Luffy, to carry forward. Remaining dead, his unfulfilled promises, such as to the Fishmen, highlight the importance of sacrifice for meaningful change.
His story strengthens the idea of inherited will, where dreams and ideals live beyond one person. Joy Boy’s absence keeps the mystery of the Void Century alive, adding tension to the plot. As a symbol, his story inspires hope, allowing other characters to grow without being overshadowed.
2) Gol D. Roger
Gol D. Roger's death is crucial to the One Piece story, as it started the Great Pirate Era and inspired many to chase their dreams. His execution fueled the search for the One Piece and symbolized freedom and rebellion against the World Government.
Roger’s absence lets Luffy create his own path without being overshadowed while highlighting the idea of the "Will of D." passing through generations. His death keeps the story exciting by raising the stakes and ensuring new characters face real challenges. Staying dead preserves Roger's legacy, the mystery of his treasure, and the series’ themes of adventure and freedom.
3) Rocks D. Xebec
Rocks D. Xebec’s death is essential to One Piece’s story. His defeat by Roger and Garp closed a major conflict, showing the victory of order over chaos. Rocks’ influence continues through Blackbeard, who mirrors his ambition, letting the story explore inherited will without bringing Rocks back.
Reviving him would shift focus from the new generation, weakening their development and the theme of passing on the torch. His death keeps the God Valley incident meaningful, preserving its historical importance. It also maintains tension in the story by letting new dangers arise naturally instead of relying on past villains.
4) Edward Newgate (Whitebeard)
Edward Newgate, or Whitebeard, needs to stay dead in One Piece because his death is key to the story. It marks the end of the Golden Age of Pirates and clears the way for new pirates like Luffy and Blackbeard to take charge. His sacrifice also inspires the next generation of pirates, especially with the confirmation of One Piece’s existence.
Whitebeard's death shows the serious stakes of the story and helps Luffy grow. It also strengthens Blackbeard’s rise to power. His passing sets a tone of unpredictability for the final saga while ensuring his legacy lives on through others.
5) Dr. Vegapunk (Stella)
Dr. Vegapunk's death in One Piece is important for the story in several ways. It triggers a message that reveals key secrets about the Void Century and the true nature of the One Piece, weakening the World Government’s control over history. His death also leaves a lasting legacy, motivating characters like Luffy, while raising emotional stakes for the crew.
It brings closure to his character arc and ensures the story doesn't rely too much on his genius, allowing other characters to step up and face challenges on their own, without relying on Vegapunk’s inventions or knowledge.
6) Kozuki Oden
Kozuki Oden's death is important to One Piece, driving change in Wano and inspiring characters like the Akazaya Nine to fight for freedom. His sacrifice represents the theme of inherited will, motivating his children and followers.
His character arc finds closure through his selfless choice, making him a tragic hero. Bringing Oden back to life would weaken his growth, disrupt the story’s themes of past heroes, and lessen the emotional impact of his journey in the series.
7) Nefertari Cobra
Nefertari Cobra’s death in One Piece is important for the plot, acting as a turning point for Princess Vivi’s development as she faces her responsibilities as a leader. His sacrifice emphasizes themes of selflessness, similar to the deaths of characters like Ace and Whitebeard.
Cobra’s assassination by Imu exposes the World Government’s cruelty, raising tensions and setting up future conflicts. His death keeps the story’s emotional weight strong and drives the plot forward. Bringing Cobra back to life would reduce the stakes, weakening the impact of his sacrifice and diminishing the tension in the narrative as he would reveal to the world, the true face of the World Government.
8) Jaygarcia Saturn
Jaygarcia Saturn’s death is important for the One Piece plot because it represents a victory against oppression, helping to keep the stakes high. His death would also push character development, especially for Bonney and the Straw Hats, and bring closure to the World Government’s darker actions.
Letting Saturn survive would have left a constant threat on Bonney and Kuma, hence reducing the tension in future storylines.
9) Nico Olvia
Nico Olvia's death is essential for shaping her daughter Robin's character and the story in One Piece. Robin’s loss drives her quest to uncover the Void Century and the Poneglyphs, with her survivor's guilt adding emotional depth. Olvia’s sacrifice represents selflessness and the dangers faced by those seeking the truth in a world ruled by the World Government.
Her death raises the stakes for future conflicts and strengthens Robin’s relationships with the Straw Hat crew. If Olvia were alive, it would lessen the emotional impact and the importance of Robin’s journey, keeping the story's themes strong.
10) Kozuki Toki
Kozuki Toki’s death in One Piece is important for the story. Her sacrifice, sending her children to the future to fulfill Oden's dream, represents hope in difficult times and motivates characters like Momonosuke and the Red Scabbards. Without Toki, Momonosuke grows into a leader on his own.
Her death raises the stakes in Wano’s conflict. Toki's passing also makes the prophecy of the nine samurai avenging Oden more powerful. Her ability to control time reflects the series' themes of fate and the idea that the past can’t be changed, which makes her death necessary for the story.
Final thoughts
Death often carries deep narrative weight, shaping the series’ themes of sacrifice, inherited will, and freedom. Keeping characters like Joy Boy, Gol D. Roger, and Whitebeard dead ensures their legacies endure while propelling the story forward. Their absence preserves emotional stakes, fostering growth for new generations of heroes.
Related links:
- The Thousand Sunny may not be the Straw Hats' last ship in One Piece
- The One Piece may be a fruit, but not a Devil Fruit
- Louis Arnot's warning may be a clever callback to one of One Piece's best flashbacks