"No Marcus Stroman? What are we doing?"; "He's a**" - Yankees fans split over 2x All-Star pitcher's ALDS roster exclusion

The New York Yankees’ decision to leave Marcus Stroman off of their 26-man roster for the ALDS has caused a stir among fans. Stroman was signed on a two-year deal this offseason and was expected to bolster the rotation for October.

However, after a rough 2024 season marked by a decline in velocity and a 4.31 ERA, the Yankees opted to leave out the two-time All-Star from the roster for the series against the Kansas City Royals.

The news of Stroman not making the 26-man roster has fans divided. Some are questioning the move, arguing that a veteran with postseason experience could offer value:

"Holmes over Stroman is crazy," posted another fan.

Other fans are frustrated with Stroman’s performance in 2024:

"Stroman sucks, right call," added another fan.

Marcus Stroman’s September was particularly rough, posting an 8.80 ERA in his final five starts. His sinker, which once was very effective, lost speed and dropped to a career-low 90 mph, contributing to his struggles.

As the season progressed, his ability to strikeout batters diminished, taking a significant role in the team's decision.

---

Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodon will lead the Yankees for the first two games of the series

The Yankees will instead rely on their top starters, Gerrit Cole and Carlos Rodon, with Luis Gil and Clarke Schmidt also in the mix for the series.

Fans are eager to see if this roster decision pays off, but it’s clear that leaving Stroman off has sparked a passionate debate about the direction of the team in the postseason.

New York finished the regular season with a record of 94-68, taking the AL East pennant for the 21st time in franchise history and clinching the first seed in the playoffs.

Game 1 of the ALDS kicks off tonight (Saturday, October 5) at 8:38 ET in the Bronx.

​