AFC executive evaluates Caleb Williams on road to NFL Draft 2024 - "He does some crazy s---"

The evaluations on Caleb Williams have been finished, and there's no real doubt that he's the number one quarterback in the 2024 draft class. The Chicago Bears have all but selected him with the first overall pick, and this will be confirmed on Thursday, April 25.

What makes Caleb Williams such a great player is obvious at first sight, but that doesn't mean that, with a deeper analysis of his game, you can pick some of his flaws - no quarterback is perfect, remember. With the top prospects of this year's class judged by NFL executives and coaches, one analysis stood out on Williams' game:

The only thing you really don't like, just strictly on the player, is the height, He's reckless. He does some crazy s---. But at the same time, he creates a lot of big plays. I think you're just gonna have to live with a little bit of that. A lot of arm talent. He's shorter. He's built differently than Bryce was. He's got more thickness to himself. Real confident and instinctive, and you can feel that on tape.

Why is Caleb Williams such a great player?

Williams is the type of player molded to perfection, always thought of as the poster boy: five-star recruit coming out of high school, college football star, Heisman Trophy winner, likely first pick in the NFL Draft. He's used to the feeling of being the star, and will have to live with that responsibility on the biggest stage.

According to 247Sports, a renowned platform for analyzing players entering their college careers, Caleb Williams had a 99 rating during the 2021 recruiting class, the eighth highest that year and the second-best quarterback (Quinn Ewers, now playing for Texas, was first in both cases). He followed Lincoln Riley from Oklahoma to USC in 2022 and, as a starter, showed all the talent to justify the hype.

Is there any guarantee that he will be all that in the NFL? Obviously not - if the draft was an exact science, we wouldn't spend so much time discussing and evaluating prospects. What matters is that Chicago Bears will have on their hands a player thought to be great from the start. Just don't run over the process.

​