Deshaun Watson risked suspension as details emerge from closed sexual assault case
The NFL's investigation into Deshaun Watson has unraveled a web of legal strategies. The September 2024 sexual assault allegations against the quarterback brought fresh scrutiny to his already controversial career.
Deshaun Watson's journey with the Cleveland Browns has not been smooth. Acquired from the Houston Texans in a trade that cost three draft picks, he's been attracting controversy ever since. His 2022 season began with an 11-game suspension for previous sexual misconduct allegations.
The latest case differs from earlier accusations. While previous allegations involved massage therapy misconduct, this new claim specifically alleged sexual assault. The accuser sought more than $1 million in compensation before settling.
"We don't meet with the NFL. We settled the case. We have nothing else to say about it," said Tony Buzbee, the attorney representing the accuser, in an email to the Washington Post.
The NFL's investigation hit a critical roadblock. Despite multiple attempts to interview the accuser, the league found itself stymied by a confidentiality agreement. NFL spokesman Brian McCarthy ultimately concluded:
"The matter is closed. There was insufficient evidence to support a finding of a violation of the personal conduct policy."
Thanks to this ruling, the quarterback avoided another suspension. Having been through one before, another would have been very detrimental to Watson's career.
Deshaun Watson's contract haunts Browns
Deshaun Watson's legal strategy potentially saved him $92 million in guaranteed money. By settling quickly, he prevented a suspension that could have voided his contract. The Browns remain committed, having extended a five-year, $230 million contract in 2022.
The financial implications are devastating for the team. Watson has played just 19 games for the Browns. His on-field performance remains disappointing, with a meager 9-10 record since arriving in Cleveland.
The team faces a critical crossroads. They must either reinstate Watson when healthy or release him, absorbing a massive salary cap hit. His replacement, Jameis Winston, has managed only a 2-3 record in late October.
If Deshaun Watson had been suspended for this latest accusation, the Browns could have voided $46 million in guaranteed pay for 2025 and 2026. The confidentiality agreement effectively closed that potential escape route.
The NFL's investigative limitations are stark. Without subpoena power, the league relies on voluntary cooperation. Watson's settlement demonstrates a masterful legal maneuver that protects his financial interests.
The Browns continue to grapple with the consequences. Their roster-building efforts are hamstrung by Watson's massive contract.