Why did the XFL fail in 2001? Looking at the origin of The Rock's football league
The XFL now seems to be getting the media and fans' attention as the NFL season is over. The league has grown considerably since its relaunch in 2020. However, it was a failed project when it was initially launched in the early years of the 21st century.
The XFL was founded as a joint venture between the WWE and NBC. It was spearheaded by Vince McMahon and Dick Ebersol. The intention behind the launch was to create a league with a unique brand of football. It was intended to be more exciting and entertaining than the NFL.
Who did it better? #XFL @XFL2023
2001 vs 2023 https://t.co/pB8n5qSWnx
The league, therefore, introduced different innovations to create fun and excitement in games. This included a shorter play clock, no fair catches on punts, and a "scramble" for the opening kickoff. However, the XFL failed to achieve its objectives and folded after just a season.
In this article, we will explore the crucial reasons behind the XFL's initial failure and why the league didn't achieve its objectives despite loads of effort that went into its establishment.
Sights & Sounds 🔊
Top moments from Week 1 getting us ready for Week 2 games to start tonight in Seattle.
#XFL2023 https://t.co/2kYv8Ufbpc
Poor quality of play
The goal and promise of the XFL were to create a league with more action and excitement. However, the games were often marred by poor execution and sloppy play. The league had to rely heavily on gimmicks such as pyrotechnics, cheerleaders, and over-the-top commentary to make up for the lackluster performances.
Low ratings and attendance
The XFL was highly publicized with aggressive marketing campaigns during its launch. However, the league recorded an abrupt decline in TV ratings after the first few weeks of action. It was reported that NBC, who was the XFL's broadcast partner, suffered a loss of $35 million because of low viewership.
Attendance at XFL games was also poor, with many venues recording less than half of their capacity. This is obviously due to poor quality of play and lack of star power.
Controversy and negative publicity
The XFL from the outset was seen as a sideshow and was often referred to as the “wrestling league” due to McMahon's involvement. The league, moreover, also focused on violence and aggression, as exemplified by its “no fair catch” rule.
Its use of ridiculous player nicknames also drew criticism in certain quarters. There were also off-field incidents involving the players, which weren’t good for the image of the league.
Conflicts of interest
The XFL was created as a joint venture between the WWE and NBC. The inability of both parties to properly balance their interests contributed to the demise of the league.
NBC, which had lost its NFL TV rights to CBS, wanted to produce a quality product that would appeal to viewers. WWE wanted to create an entertaining spectacle and promote its wrestlers. This disagreement over the direction of the league hindered its chances of success
Financial instability
The XFL was reported to have launched with an investment worth $100 million from the WWE and NBC. The venture, however, grew to be financially unsustainable and lost a lot of money.
The league reportedly suffered a loss of $70 million in its first season alone. Attempts to secure additional funding for the XFL's second season were futile. This was the last straw that broke the camel's back. The XFL eventually folded in May 2001 after the completion of its first season.