Sharks-Penguins-Karlsson Trade Hockey — San Jose Sharks defenseman Erik Karlsson against the Pittsburgh Penguins during the third period of an NHL hockey game in San Jose, Calif., Feb. 14, 2023. The Pittsburgh Penguins have acquired Karlsson in a blockbuster trade with the Sharks. Pittsburgh traded a 2024 first-round pick, forward Mikael Granlund and defenseman Jan Rutta to San Jose and goaltender Casey DeSmith and defenseman Jeff Petry to Montreal as part of the deal for the reigning Norris Trophy winner. (AP Photo/Godofredo A. Vásquez)

San Jose Sharks Offseason Graded: A mixed bag of moves reflecting an identity crisis

Modified Aug 12, 2023 04:31 GMT

The San Jose Sharks' offseason was a flurry of activity as the team grappled with the aftermath of another disappointing playoff absence. The roster was reshaped through a series of trades, signings, and re-signings, leaving fans and analysts pondering the team's direction and identity.

Here's a closer look at the Sharks' key moves and grade their offseason performance:

#1. Trading Erik Karlsson - Grade: D+

The offseason kicked off with a major shocker as the Sharks traded away Erik Karlsson, a former Norris Trophy winner and one of the franchise's marquee players. In return, they received Mikael Granlund, Jan Rutta, Mike Hoffman and a first-round pick.

While the trade provided a substantial return, it's hard to overlook the loss of Karlsson's undeniable star power and impact on the blue line. The package, though valuable, might not adequately compensate for a player of Karlsson's caliber. Grade: D+

#2. The San Jose Sharks Trading for MacKenzie Blackwood - Grade: A+

Acquiring MacKenzie Blackwood for a mere sixth-round pick stands out as one of the offseason's most impressive moves. Blackwood adds a strong presence between the pipes and bolsters the team's goaltending depth. For a minimal cost, the Sharks secured a potentially game-changing asset. Grade: A+

#3. Re-Signing Fabian Zetterlund - Grade: C+

The Sharks' decision to re-sign RFA Fabian Zetterlund demonstrates a commitment to developing internal talent. While Zetterlund's potential is recognized, the move doesn't carry a significant impact on the team's overall dynamics. Grade: C+

#4. Trading for Anthony Duclair - Grade: B+

The trade that brought Anthony Duclair, along with Steven Lorentz and a fifth-round pick, injected fresh blood into the Sharks' lineup. Duclair's offensive skills could add a much-needed scoring punch.

However, the loss of Lorentz and a draft pick might temper the enthusiasm for this move. Grade: B+

#5. Signing Low-Risk Depth Pieces - Grade: C+

The San Jose Sharks' approach to signing depth players, such as Givani Smith and Ryan Carpenter, reflects a prudent strategy to add support to the roster without incurring substantial risk. While these signings might not grab headlines, they contribute to the team's overall depth. Grade: C+

The San Jose Sharks' offseason moves are a mixed bag of calculated risks and strategic maneuvers. The front office's attempts to reinvigorate the roster and establish a clear direction are evident, though some moves might not resonate as strongly as others.

As the new season unfolds, the true impact of these decisions will be revealed, and fans will be eagerly watching to see how the Sharks navigate their path back to the playoffs and beyond.