5 WWE stars who can replace Carlito in The Judgment Day
The Judgment Day is one of the most prominent factions in WWE and has been dominating Monday Night RAW for quite some time. The group has undergone massive changes in the course of the last few months. However, there are reports surfacing lately that one of its members—Carlito—is likely to find his way out of the group sooner than later.
Since then, rumors have been swirling that Finn Balor could be devising a massive plot to kick him out of the group. The seeds of The Caribbean Cool's potential exit may have been planted last night on RAW when the members of his stable looked quite grumpy with him. Therefore, this lightens up the possibility of the latter being replaced with a new star in the weeks to come.
Let's look at five superstars who could replace Carlito in The Judgment Day:
#5. Cedric Alexander
One of the names who has the potential to join The Judgment Day is Cedric Alexander. The latter recently inked a new deal with WWE, and this seems to be a major indication that the company may have some plans for him down the line. Therefore, it gives rise to the possibility that he could replace Carlito in the heel faction in the coming weeks.
Moreover, this would also provide a fresh start for the 35-year-old, who has been seeking a major program for years. It will also elevate Cedric Alexader as a credible heel on the RAW roster. He is a multi-time champion in WWE, which gives him the credibility to become Carlito's potential replacement in this new iteration of The Judgment Day.
Furthermore, the 35-year-old has enough experience in working with a faction, given his past with The Hurt Business. Therefore, seeing him in The Judgment Day could be an exciting dynamic that the fans might enjoy.
#4. Pete Dunne
Pete Dunne is another name that has the potential to be the next member of The Judgment Day after Carlito's potential departure from the group. The 30-year-old was recently embroiled in an intense feud with Sheamus. Therefore, WWE might add him to Finn Balor's crew and push him as a big star on RAW.
Considering his history with Balor, The Bruiserweight could be an intriguing addition to the faction. He can provide the intensity and seriousness to The Judgment Day, which it currently lacks. Besides, with the wicked wrestling style of Dunne, he can drastically elevate the presence of the heel stable.
Moreover, it would definitely be an interesting scenario for fans to see a funny character like Carlito replaced by a polar opposite, Pete Dunne.
#3. Bronco Nima
Bronco Nima is a rising star on NXT who has been seeking the spotlight. He has been performing incredibly well on the developmental brand. However, there has been a lack of creative direction for him on the brand. Therefore, WWE might call Nima up to the main roster and add him to The Judgment Day as a new member of the group after Carlito's potential exit.
Besides, it would provide the 33-year-old an opportunity to flaunt his talent on the main roster. In addition to that, he has an incredible stature that makes him stand out among many on NXT. Hence, Bronco Nima could be an outstanding addition to Balor's group that might help the faction serve its purpose of putting over talent.
Moreover, the NXT Superstar could also elevate his skills under the wing of a veteran like Finn Balor, which could benefit him in the future in his professional wrestling career.
#2. Omos
Omos could be a shocking name who might join The Judgment Day down the line. The 30-year-old has been away from WWE television since April 2024. However, the creative team might bring him back and add him to Finn Balor's faction as Carlito's potential replacement.
The Nigerian Giant could serve as an enforcer for the group and a potential bodyguard for The Prince. This would also make The Judgment Day look like a legitimate threat on Monday Night RAW. Adding Omos to the faction would also help him to revive his character, which has lost its spark.
Besides, the addition of The Nigerian Giant could be a game-changer for the RAW faction. In fact, it can help Balor and his crew in going up against stars like Braun Strowman and even Gunther, given their muscle power.
#1. Oba Femi could join The Judgment Day
Oba Femi is one of the most promising stars on NXT. Although he is currently embroiled in the NXT North American Title picture, there are chances that he might get a main-roster call-up soon. In a shocking turn of events, Finn Balor might unveil the 26-year-old as a new member of The Judgment Day in the coming weeks after Carlito's rumored exit.
Femi carries the potential of a main event star. Debuting in the popular faction would kickstart his main roster journey on a high note. He could work as the muscle of the group in Balor's dirty tactics. Meanwhile, Oba Femi could also sharpen his skills while working as an accomplice of the faction before he goes on a singles run in WWE.
Furthermore, this would also help WWE in establishing the 26-year-old as a major star before catapulting him into the main event scene. All in all, it could prove to be one of the biggest additions to The Judgment Day that could prove to be a game-changer for the heel faction.