How historically accurate is Yellowstone? Fact-checking all important aspects of the show

Modified Dec 25, 2024 07:30 GMT

Yellowstone—the modern Western series created by Taylor Sheridan—has captivated audiences since its debut in 2018. Featuring the dramatic lives of the Dutton family, the show is a compelling mix of family drama, power struggles, and stunning landscapes. Season 5, part 2, premiered on December 15, 2024, on Paramount Network.

The series centers on the Dutton family, owners of Montana's largest ranch. Patriarch John Dutton leads the family through conflicts with land developers, tribal nations, and even themselves. Contemporary ranching is portrayed as a mix of tradition, survival, and wealth.

Detailed Western lifestyle depictions make the Paramount series authentic. Creator Taylor Sheridan's ranching background adds realism. However, several show elements are exaggerated for drama.

Fact-checking Yellowstone’s depiction of ranch life

Authentic representation of ranching heritage

Yellowstone captures the Dutton family's dedication to ranching, reflecting the real-life tradition of family-owned ranches. This multi-generational stewardship shows the Duttons' deep connection to their land, a common trait among ranching families. Creator Taylor Sheridan adds ranching knowledge to the story, making it more authentic.

The series exaggerates the Duttons' wealth with private helicopters and cutting-edge equipment. Most ranchers focus on sustainability and practical investments with modest means. This enhances the show's drama and scale but deviates from ranching families' financial realities.

Genuine family dynamics amidst ranching challenges

A still from the show (Image via Paramount+)

The complex family relationships in the series reflect ranching families' close bonds and tensions. Working with relatives often combines personal and professional lives, which can lead to conflict and emotional strain.

Real ranchers know that managing a family-run business requires navigating complex interpersonal dynamics that can affect business and family harmony.

The Paramount series takes these issues and dramatizes them with extreme dysfunction and frequent violence. In reality, disagreements are usually resolved through communication and compromise rather than violent confrontations like on the show.

Exaggerated depiction of violence for dramatic effect

Violence drives the story of Yellowstone and gives a path to a certain tension. The series amplifies intense confrontations and aggressive behavior beyond ranching disputes for entertainment. While disagreements and conflicts are inevitable in ranching communities, they rarely reach the extremes shown in the series.

To maintain operations and community relationships, ranchers prioritize safety, cooperation, and conflict resolution. Crude language and physical altercations make the show gripping, but ranching life is more about hard work, resilience, and mutual support than constant danger and violence.

Urbanization and the threat to ranch lands

One of the main conflicts in Yellowstone is the fight to keep the Dutton family ranch safe from developers and growing cities. The problems in this story are similar to those that ranchers all over the United States face.

As more people move to cities, the demand for land in rural areas has gone through the roof, often destroying ranches that have been there for a long time. Developers see large ranch lands as great places to build homes, businesses, or recreational estates. This forces ranchers to protect their heritage and way of life.

This problem got worse during the COVID-19 pandemic when many people from cities moved to the country to find more space and a calmer way of life. Property values went up because of this migration, making it harder for ranching families to compete with wealthy buyers and developers.

The high-stakes fights in Yellowstone make these conflicts seem more dramatic, but the real problem in rural America is that it's hard to balance protecting the land with modern development. This tension shows how delicate the balance is between tradition and progress.

Authentic Western wear as it is shown on screen

Yellowstone meticulously depicts rancher attire with Kimes Ranch, American Hat, and Greeley Hat. Taylor Sheridan focuses on authenticity, so characters wear real-life gear. Rip Wheeler looks like a true rancher, while John Dutton mixes business and rancher styles.

Realism is enhanced by accurately depicting most ranch workers' outfits. Jimmy's first-season hat, which looks like festival wear rather than ranch wear, is the only minor difference.

Presence of real rodeo professionals

A still from Yellowstone (Image via Paramount Plus)

Real rodeo athletes perform reining and other equestrian skills to enhance the show's realism. Professional riders, not actors, are skilled and authentic in horseback scenes.

Their real-life interactions and horse knowledge make Yellowstone's ranching and competition more believable. This integration honors rodeo competitors' expertise, ensuring that horse handling and rodeo activities are portrayed accurately.

Deep land and heritage commitment

Beth and Rip from Yellowstone season 5 (Image via Paramount Plus)

Real ranchers share the Dutton family's pride in their land and cattle. They emphasize family, tradition, and ranch life's rewards. This sincerity shows ranchers' passion for culture and heritage, presenting Yellowstone as a way of life rooted in history and family.

Yellowstone tells a compelling story about modern ranch life using fact and fiction. The ranching background of Taylor Sheridan and the detailed depiction of Western culture gives it authenticity. Land encroachment and family strife are the Duttons' problems. However, extreme wealth, violence, and profanity are exaggerated for drama.

The series has won viewers over with its blend of realism and storytelling while revealing ranching's complexities. The show portrays a traditional and resilient lifestyle well despite its exaggerations.

All seasons of Yellowstone can be streamed on Paramount+.